The 6 Best Eyeliners for Waterline in 2021

Find out our top picks for best eyeliner products for the waterline

Want a flawless tight line that won’t smudge or leave eyes looking like you’ve watched the end of Titanic 17 times? These bold, stay-put liners will help you rock a seamless waterline look.

Jane Iredale Eye Pencil Crayon - close up of eye with blended grey and white eyeshadow and eye pencil applying blue shade to waterline - 650 x 433Jane Iredale Eye Pencil Crayon - close up of eye with blended grey and white eyeshadow and eye pencil applying blue shade to waterline - 650 x 433

"Very creamy on the end so its soft around the eyes and easy to use on the waterline without having that scratchy feeling like some eye pencils" - Aron ★★★★★

M.A.C, an industry leader in pro-quality cosmetics that delight consumers and professional makeup artists alike, rarely disappoints, and the M.A.C Cosmetics Pro Longwear Eye Liner is no exception. A creamy gel pencil, this comfortable formula glides on effortlessly and locks down instantly for up to 12 hours of wear on the lid and 6 hours of wear in the water line, minimising the need for touch-ups and keeping your eye look on point all day long. In a variety of richly pigmented shades that create whatever look you’re going for, M.A.C Cosmetics Pro Longwear Eye Liner stays put for long-lasting cat eyes or solid, subtle tight lining. Safe for those with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, you know you’re in good hands with M.A.C Cosmetics Pro Longwear Eye Liner.

This water resistant, richly pigmented formula applies easily and sets quickly for a long-lasting look that won't let you down.

"I saw this advertised on a beauty blog and had to try it! I wasn't disappointed - perfect for those with oily skin or watery eyes because it is smudge proof and stays put all day! The pencil is lovely and soft so glides over the skin without pulling or scratching, you can smudge really quick if you want a smoky look or it will dry in place. The colour of this one is a lovely dark brown and quite pigmented...will definitely buy them in other colours! Highly recommend the sharpener from Eye of Horus to use with it!" - Lisa ★★★★★

Nourish your lids and lashes while creating stunning eye looks with Eye Of Horus Goddess Pencil. Richly pigmented and available in both brightening shades and deep, dark shades, the Eye Of Horus Goddess Pencil is the perfect choice for those with easily irritated, dry, or sensitive eyes due to its' creamy, irritant free formula. This unique, award-winning formula glides on to lids and the water line without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin in the eye area, minimising the visible signs of aging and keeping eyes tear-free throughout wear. The key ingredient in this liner is moringa oil, a nutrient and antioxidant packed oil that has calming and soothing properties, making this a killer choice for those with sensitive eyes. Vegan carnauba wax rounds out the formula, keeping your look locked in place for all day wear.

Containing natural ingredients, this is perfect for those with even the most sensitive of eyes. You are sure to fall in love with a richly pigmented and creamy texture, this liner is available in 9 different shades

"This eyeliner goes on very smoothly. Love knowing there is no nasty chemicals in it. Looks great every time. Already put in another order in a different colour, now I know how good it is" - Kam ★★★★★

Bring the soothing power of mineral makeup to your eye looks with Inika Mineral Eye Liner. Inika specialises in high-quality mineral cosmetics, creating natural, stunning products that are easy to use and gentle on skin, and their Mineral Eye Liner exemplifies that mission perfectly. This smooth, silky formula glides on to the lid and water line, providing luxe, all day wear and intense pigmentation for a longwear look with an all-natural formula that won’t stress eyes out. A great choice for those looking to refine their routine with ethical products, this liner is cruelty-free, vegan, paraben free, and naturally formulated for a liner that looks as good as it makes you feel. Suitable for all eyes, this organic formula won’t smudge or transfer, locking in for all day wear no matter what the day throws at you.

Designed to glide on with ease, Inika Mineral Eye Liner lasts all day without smudging or fading. These handcrafted, certified organic liners have a rich and creamy texture that’s unmatched in the natural eyeliner cosmetics category.

"I think I’ve tried thousands of eyeliner only to have it under my eyes within hours and I don’t even have oily skin! I haven’t used this to tightline but I’ve used it for a quick daily flick and it hasn’t budged! I like the dark brown for a cool toned natural look. Very happy." - Tanya ★★★★☆

From bold black to vibrant violet, build whatever look you’re dreaming of with the Designer Brands Pigment Plus Retractable Eye Pencil. This stay-put liner is retractable for easy sharpening and comes in a wide variety of shades to help you achieve your perfect liner look. A water-resistant formula, you can rock this easy to use pencil on the lid or the waterline for a look that won’t smudge, budge, or disappear throughout the day. A great choice for those who like to switch up their look on the go, this self-sharpening pencil fits perfectly in your purse for travel or touch-ups throughout the day. The safe, gentle formula is comfortable for eyes and free of irritants, giving you the peace of mind you need to rock any look, from subtle to sexy, all day long.

Natural, Long-Lasting Pigments

"This eyeliner is lovely to use. I have super sensitive eyes and this product does not irritate it. The formula is nice and creamy but does not smudge easily unless you rub your eyes. Really recommend it for an everyday eyeliner" - Leonie ★★★★★

Natural, Long-Lasting Pigments

Get the ultimate in safe, comfortable all day wear with Jane Iredale Eye Pencil Crayon. Jane Iredale’s commitment to creating incredible, naturally-based cosmetics comes through with this creamy eye pencil, minimising irritation and staying locked in place throughout wear with no stress to your eyes. Bold, intense pigments deposit smooth, even colour on the lid and in the waterline, with a waterproof finish that stands up to smudges, tearing, and everything in between for longwear that’s comfortable for eyes. Great for those looking for a more natural option, this liner is free of FD&C dyes, making it safe for even the most sensitive areas like the upper lash line and waterline. You’ll look fab all day without irritation with Jane Iredale Eye Pencil Crayon.

Enhance your eyes and create looks ranging from subtle to dramatic. Natural mineral pigments provide long-wearing colours that stay put. Creamy and easy to apply, this eyeliner defines without pulling the delicate eye area.

"I like to line under the lashes on my top lid, filling in the waterline to make my lashes look thicker. This is THE BEST for that. I can’t get a perfect line above the lashes with it, but good for a smudgy look." - Emma ★★★★★

Hitting the beach or taking a hike may seem like a wise time to forgo liner, but pro artist Bobbi Brown lets you hit the surf or sand in style with Bobbi Brown Long Wear Waterproof Liner. This heavy duty, opaque formula is built to last through even the hottest, most humid conditions, making this an ideal choice for those on a luxe vacation or those simply looking for a liner that will outlast their workout. The rich, densely pigmented formula glides on without pulling or tugging and lasts all day without irritation, providing a comfortable, easy to wear liner that’s water resistant for tackling any situation while keeping your liner totally on point. Create any number of looks with the precise, swivel-up pencil tip and decent range of shades for a perfect, budge-proof finish that will last all day long.

Discover which are the 10 Best Mascaras That Give Length and Volume in 2021

Adore Beauty and M.A.C Cosmetics join forces to showcase the range:

So, Let's Recap!

The 6 Best Eyeliners for Waterline in 2021

  1. M.A.C Cosmetics Pro Longwear Eye Liner

  2. Eye Of Horus Goddess Pencil

  3. Inika Mineral Eye Liner

  4. Designer Brands Pigment Plus Retractable Eye Pencil

  5. Jane Iredale Eye Pencil Crayon

  6. Bobbi Brown Long Wear Waterproof Liner

Brand and product inclusions are at the sole discretion of Adore Beauty’s highly trained Customer Service team. We do not seek or accept payment from brands or individuals listed in our guides.

This article has been updated on 15/02 to replace discontinued products with our recent product recommendations. Brooklyn from our Customer Service team has helped to bring you our most recommended products and up-to-date information.

    Join Now >
    Filled with the usual things we know you'll love, and surprises you might not expect, it's real rewards, really simple.